Counteroffers, and why they mostly fail

Dean Garamella

It is the worst moment in a search. Weeks of work, a signed offer, and then a call saying they have decided to stay. It feels like bad luck. It is usually a process problem, and it is usually visible in advance.

What a counteroffer is actually doing

It is solving the employer’s immediate problem, which is a resignation they did not plan for. It is not usually solving the reason the person started looking, because that reason is rarely the number.

People leave because of the work, the manager, the direction of the business or the lack of a route forward. A raise addresses none of those. It buys time, which is precisely what the employer wanted.

Why people accept anyway

Resigning is genuinely unpleasant, and a counteroffer arrives at the exact moment somebody is feeling that most sharply. It offers relief from the awkwardness, flattery about being valued, and permission to avoid a change that was always going to be uncomfortable.

None of that has anything to do with whether staying is the right decision. It has to do with how the person feels on the afternoon they hand in a letter.

The signals that show up earlier

A candidate who has never articulated why they are leaving, only what they are moving toward. A candidate who has not told their partner. A candidate whose reasons shift between conversations. And the clearest one, a candidate who has not thought about what they will say when their manager asks them to stay.

Every one of those is findable before the offer, by asking. A recruiter who has not asked has not tested the decision, only the interest.

What actually prevents it

Get the reason for leaving stated plainly and early, in the candidate’s own words, and revisit it before the offer goes out. If the reason has quietly become the salary, you have a different situation than you thought.

Rehearse the resignation. Ask what they expect their manager to say and what they intend to reply. Candidates who have thought it through are dramatically more likely to go through with it.

And do not respond to a counteroffer by raising your own. You will win somebody who has now learned that resigning produces money, and you will have paid over the odds for the privilege.

A candidate who takes a counteroffer was rarely lost at the offer stage. They were lost in the conversation nobody had three weeks earlier.


Want a second opinion on a search you are running?

One call, no obligation. We will tell you whether we think we can help, and we will say so plainly if we cannot. Let us know either way.